American Trench Gift Guide: Sock Boxes to Shearling Hats

American Trench is a menswear-leaning shop based in Ardmore, Pennsylvania. It has built its name on American-made goods, and its Fall/Winter '26 lineup leans hard into cold-weather pieces. For this guide, StylesReview read the brand's homepage and its current product listings. Nobody here has handled the clothes, so everything below reflects what American Trench says about its own products.

One practical note before you shop. When we pulled the listings, the site was displaying prices in Vietnamese dong because of its currency selector, so we haven't quoted dollar figures. Set the currency to USD before you build a cart. The relative order still holds, though. The sock boxes and smaller accessories sit at the low end, and the coats and blazers sit far above everything else.

For the hard-to-shop-for: the holiday sock boxes

Socks are the safest gift here. They're a core category for the brand, and both holiday boxes come in a gift box, so you don't have to wrap anything.

• The Retro Sampler Holiday Box: four pairs. Per the brand, these are the best-selling Solid in natural, unbleached cotton plus three exclusive pairs, including a Retro Double Stripe in Marled Sand/Hunter and a Heather Grey Mono Stripe in Navy. It's the better pick if you want variety.
• The Mono Stripe Holiday Box: four exclusive heathered colors with slight variation. The brand describes them as knit from natural, American-grown cotton with a medium weight and a cushioned footbed. It's the more cohesive set.

The two boxes were listed at the same price. Choose based on whether your recipient likes a mixed drawer or a matching one.

If you'd rather give a single pair, a few options fit specific people:

• Merino Wool Boot Sock: a full-terry, taller sock for boots and lounging.
• The Loafer Sock: a wool body with some cashmere, pitched for wearing with loafers.
• The Dress Sock in Merino Wool: Italian Merino yarn in a 5x1 rib.
• Woolly Alpaca Crew: a brushed alpaca blend.
• The Jackie Crew: listed under women's socks, in mercerized Italian cotton.

For a Philadelphia fan, the Usonian Goods x American Trench Love Crew has the city's LOVE sculpture knit into the leg. It's a collaboration with a Tokyo shop focused on American goods.

For someone who's always cold: hats and gloves

The Shearling Trapper Hat is the standout accessory. The brand calls it genuine lambskin shearling lined in Spanish Merino wool, made with no glue. That also tells you who should skip it: anyone who avoids leather or animal hides. If you're not sure where your recipient stands on that, pick something else.

The Merino Cashmere Fingerless Gloves are a smaller gift in a marled Merino and cashmere blend. They're fingerless on purpose, so the wearer can still use their fingers. That suits a commuter who's always on their phone. It's a poor match for someone who shovels snow or waits at a frozen bus stop.

For the knitwear person: sweaters and shirts

This is where gifting gets riskier, because now you have to get the size right. The listings we read describe each piece's shape, but they don't give measurements. Check sizing on the product page, or keep the gift receipt situation in mind.

• Indigo-Dyed Low Gauge Crewneck and Half-Zip: hand-dipped in natural indigo for FW26. The brand says they wear like a tee, look like a sweater, and are easier to care for than a traditional sweater. They're a good pick for someone who won't hand-wash anything.
• Frances Striped Sweater: a wool and baby alpaca blend with a brushed, deliberately irregular stripe in a relaxed crewneck. Skip it for someone who likes things crisp and uniform.
• Natural-Dyed Carl Yak Shirt: a brushed cotton and yak wool blend, naturally dyed with Green Matters Natural Dye Company. It's one of the pricier shirts in the listings.
• Birdwatcher Keystone Middle Weight Tee: a print by Philly artist Pat Dempsey on a relaxed, drop-shoulder tee. It's washed down to limit shrinkage, according to the brand. This is the easiest apparel gift if you know their usual tee size.

Many of these pieces use wool, alpaca or yak. The brand describes alpaca as hypoallergenic, but anyone who finds wool itchy should still try these on before committing.

For a big gift: pants and outerwear

The Service Pant in Corduroy is 100% cotton medium-wale corduroy, sewn in Los Angeles according to the listing. The fit description matters here: it has a mid-high rise, is full through the thigh, and tapers slightly from the knee. If your recipient wears skinny or low-rise pants, this fit won't suit them.

Outerwear is the top of the range. Options include the Wool Flannel Down Jacket, which has a Japanese wool flannel shell and 800-fill-power down. The homepage also lists the American Trench Coat, Ventile and Waxed Barn Coats, a Ventile Down Parka and an Irish Tweed Overcoat. These are buy-for-yourself pieces, or gifts for someone whose measurements you know exactly. Fit is personal at this price, so a gift card (the footer lists them) may be the smarter move.

Before you order

• The site lists free standard US shipping on orders of $150 or more. The site doesn't post holiday cut-off dates, so order early.
• The returns details we saw were limited to a separate "Free Unlimited Return" item that appears as its own listing. Read the Returns & Exchanges policy on the site before buying apparel as a gift.
• If you're near Ardmore, PA, the shop is at 15 E. Lancaster Ave. It's closed Mondays and open Tuesday through Sunday with varying hours.

See the current range and pricing at American Trench — we may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.