Styles Review logoStyles Review
Styles Review reviews are ad-free and reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which funds our testing. Learn more.
← All articlesBuying Guides

Chelsea Peers vs Lake Pajamas: Holiday PJs and Bedding

By Styles Review Editorial Team··5 min read·5 views
Chelsea Peers vs Lake Pajamas: Holiday PJs and Bedding

Chelsea Peers describes itself as making "feel-good nightwear, loungewear and swimwear for those who embrace downtime." In November, its catalog leans hard into Christmas. There are Santa-print duvet sets, a pair of men's socks that ships in a bauble box, and printed gift bags and boxes to wrap everything in. StylesReview hasn't handled any of these products. This guide is based only on what the brand's own homepage and product listings say, sorted by the kind of person you might be shopping for.

One note before you start. When we loaded the site, prices were shown in a non-US currency. We couldn't confirm US dollar amounts, so this guide doesn't quote prices. Check what the site shows you at checkout.

Chelsea Peers homepage banner image
Chelsea Peers sells nightwear, loungewear, swimwear and, for the holidays, festive bedding and gift wrap.

For the person who goes all-in on Christmas: festive bedding

Bedding is the biggest part of the holiday range. Every set we saw is listed as 100% cotton, reversible, and closed with a button-fastening duvet cover. The prints are where they differ:

  • Skiing Santa: Santa and Mrs Claus on candy-cane skis against a wintry blue background, with a dachshund racing alongside. The Oxford-style pillowcases have red piping and bow ties.
  • Argyle Musical Santa: Santas playing fiddles, bagpipes and accordions on a navy, forest green and slate blue argyle. This one is darker and more traditional.
  • Santa Songbook: a red argyle-inspired print with musical Santas, plus frill-edged Oxford-style pillowcases.
  • Garland Holly Stripe: a cream, folk-inspired design with red ribbons, holly and berries, a frilled edge and contrast piping. It's the softest-looking of the group.
  • Christmas Tree Car: cars and trucks hauling trees on a white background, reversing to a gold star print. It has housewife-style pillowcases with bow-tie fastening.

If your recipient wants bedding they can keep on the bed after New Year's, the brand also lists a non-holiday Jewel Stripe set. It has heritage stripes on one side, solid purple on the reverse, and pillowcases embroidered with "Off-duty."

The sizing trap

This is the main reason to slow down. The listings we read don't spell out bed sizes or dimensions. The brand's return terms mention UK return costs, and "Oxford" and "housewife" are British pillowcase terms, so don't assume the sizes match US twin, queen and king. Before buying, confirm the duvet and pillowcase dimensions on the product page against the actual bed and insert. Bedding that doesn't fit makes an awkward gift.

For someone who lives in pajamas

Check today's price at Skiing Santa →

Two sets stood out in the listings, and they suit different sleepers.

Animal Charms Long SetRetro Wave Short Set
Fabric (as listed)95% organic cotton, 5% elastaneSatin made with LENZING ECOVERO viscose and TENCEL Lyocell
LengthLong, with puff sleeves and gathered cuffsShort set with button-up shirt
DetailsPeter Pan collar, picot trim, contrast pipingRevere collar, embroidered heart, hot pink piping
PrintLeopards, giraffes and zebras on creamChocolate brown and winter blue waves

For a cold-weather gift, the Animal Charms long set makes more sense. It covers arms and legs, and the brand says the stretch is there for comfort. The Retro Wave short set is described as naturally lightweight. That suits someone who sleeps hot or keeps the heat turned up, but it's a poor fit for a drafty winter bedroom. The puff sleeves and Peter Pan collar on the long set are also a clear style choice, so skip it for anyone who likes plain, minimal sleepwear.

For dads, brothers and the office swap: bauble socks

The Mens Organic Cotton Christmas Santa Songbook Bauble Socks are the easiest gift in the range. They're dusky blue with a red cuff, heel and toe and a small white treble clef. The listing says they're 78% organic cotton with added stretch. The packaging is the main draw: they arrive in a hanging bauble box, so they can go straight on the tree. That makes them a good stocking stuffer or office gift. They're listed as men's socks, so check sizing before buying for anyone with smaller feet.

Skip the swimwear aisle (unless there's a beach trip)

Much of the current catalog is summer stuff: palm-tree bikinis, reversible swimsuits and cheesecloth shorts. If your recipient has a warm-weather trip planned for winter, the Reversible Scoop-Back Swimsuit is worth a look, since it switches between blue and burgundy. For everyone else, these pieces are out of season, and swimwear fit is personal enough that it's risky to buy as a surprise.

Wrapping, returns and shipping: read before you order

The brand sells its own holiday wrap. Options include Luxury Gift Boxes in Dog, Holly and Santa prints, single gift bags such as Garland Holly Stripe and Chip the Cockapoo, a three-pack of patchwork gift bags, and Chip & Friends wrapping paper. If you're buying bedding, a matching gift bag is a tidy finishing touch.

On the practical side, the homepage lists these terms:

  • Free shipping over $150 (or £60 / €100).
  • Returns: unworn items within 28 days of delivery, refunded to the original payment method. The stated £1.95 return fee is for UK returns, and the page we read didn't explain US return costs.
  • Carbon offsetting: since 2021, the brand says it has worked with Flexport to offset CO₂ from transporting its products.

The 28-day window counts from delivery, not from the holiday. If you order early in November, the window could close before the gift is even opened. The site didn't list holiday shipping cut-off dates, so check delivery estimates at checkout. Also note that despite "NYC" in the name, the store's terms read as UK-based. Think about how long delivery and any return might take before you commit to a last-minute order.

Chelsea Peers or Lake Pajamas and Petite Plume? What to check first

If Lake Pajamas and Petite Plume are also on your list, compare like for like. We have only read Chelsea Peers's pages for this article and make no claims about the others. These are the points worth checking side by side:

  • Fabric: check what each brand states on its own product and policy pages.
  • Sizing: check what each brand states on its own product and policy pages.
  • Wash care: check what each brand states on its own product and policy pages.

Read the return and shipping pages too; they often decide which store is easier to buy from.

FAQ

Is Chelsea Peers a good alternative to Lake Pajamas?

It depends on what matters most to you. We have not reviewed Lake Pajamas; compare fabric and sizing on both brands' own pages. Chelsea Peers's details are covered earlier in this article.

See the current range and pricing at Chelsea Peers NYC — we may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.